Paul’s Church, with all the roof fallen

Last week I caught a show on the building of St. Paul’s Cathedral in London. The building is so iconic (and such an interesting feat of engineering) that few people remember what came before.

Old St. Paul’s was one of the largest Gothic cathedrals in Europe, with an enormous nave known as “Paul’s Walk”, beautiful stained glass and the tallest spire in Europe.

It was not just a pretty building, but became the centre of London life–its nave was used for business, for learning the latest news, and later, during its decline, for all manner of buying and selling. London’s booksellers were located nearby on Pater Noster street. But, like many churches, the Reformation was not kind to it. By the 16th century it had begun its long decline, and was actually sacked by a mob. Horses were even bought and sold there at one point. In 1561 the spire was destroyed by lightning. A belated attempt to stop the decline was made with the addition of a classical portico in the 1630s.

However, at the moment of its death there had been hope–scaffolding had gone up to start a long-promised restoration. The scaffolding instead contributed to its demise in the Great Fire of 1666.

The cathedral lay in ruins for many years while debates raged as to what to do next–restore what was left, rebuild in a similar style, or build something completely new. The decision was eventually made to give the commission to Christopher Wren, who had done an initial investigation into restoring the church before the fire. In the meantime, the ruins stood:

The ruins did not come down until 1675, and were apparently tougher than they looked. When it came time to lay out the new church, a piece of gravestone was used to mark the centre of the new dome. Upon that gravestone, one word: Resurgam. (I shall rise again). And it did.

I retain my fondness, however, for the beautiful cathedral which fell into ruins and then perished in the fire. The sad depictions of its last few years, with its truncated spire, are particularly evocative. Today, nothing remains but a few scattered remnants of funerary momuments of the old, where bishops and counts and poets were buried–just enough to recall what came before.

One comment

  1. Reblogged this on Scilicet and commented:

    I wrote this nine years ago, and while prepping my piece on Notre-Dame de Paris, re-read it. The fact that St. Paul’s, like Notre Dame, had scaffolding up for restoration when it burned is just a little creepy. The two churches share some interesting parallels, but unfortunately, Old St. Paul’s did not survive its fire to rise again in the same form.


Comments are closed.